The Return of the Condor Heroes Chapter 14 – Part 8
Translation by Jenxi Seow
After this setback he dared not be careless again. Whirling his iron wheel, he fought with his whole mind on the fight. His opponent was only a youth still in his teens, yet he met him as he would a great enemy, respectful in attack and rigorous in defence, as though Yang Guo were the grand master of a school. At once Yang Guo felt the strain. The Dog-Beating Staff Technique was a wonderful art, but learned and used in the same breath, it could not be mastered all at once. He used the sealing principle to hold off the wheel’s attack and shifted his footing, dashing east and charging west. The State Preceptor varied his attack and defence with every move of the bamboo staff. Seeing Yang Guo break outwards, he thought it was just what he wanted, and kept falling back to draw him far from the stone formation. But after a dozen or so steps back, his right foot suddenly caught on a great rock. Without knowing it, he had been lured into the stone formation.
He knew this was bad. He heard Huang Rong calling out, one order after another, “Vermilion Bird to Azure Dragon, the xun position1 to the li position, Yi Wood to Gui Water.” The Wu brothers and Guo Fu moved the rocks, and the formation changed rapidly. The State Preceptor turned pale with alarm. He stopped his wheel, meaning to take stock of his surroundings, but Yang Guo’s bamboo staff came tangling in. Head-on, the Dog-Beating Staff Technique was not yet a match for him, but for throwing his mind into confusion it was more than enough. The State Preceptor tripped several times and could not keep his footing. He knew the stone formation was deadly: the longer he was caught in it, the more lost he would become. In his extremity he gave a great shout and leapt up onto the rocks. Once on top of the heaps, a man was free of the formation’s spell. Otherwise, with every direction confused, he might think he had only to run hard in a straight line to get out, but heading east he would come out west, heading south he would come out north, only going round and round within a hundred-odd feet until his strength gave out and he could only wait to be taken. But the moment the State Preceptor was up on the rocks, Yang Guo swung the staff at his shins. The iron wheel was a short weapon, and he could not stoop to attack or parry with it, so he had no choice but to jump down to level ground and strike back with a sweep of the wheel.
Another dozen moves, and the dusk was gathering. All around, jagged rocks rose, and the stone formation seemed to breathe a ghostly chill. Bold and highly skilled as he was, even he felt a creeping dread. Then suddenly a flash of inspiration came to him, and he had a plan. The stones in the formation were large and small: the large ones were hard to move, but the small ones he could deal with. His left foot scooped up, and a big rock of more than twenty jin2 went flying into the air. His right leg swept out after it, and another big rock flew high. His body flickered as both legs scooped in turn, and several of the smaller rocks crashed together with a noise to shake the hills, sparks and stone chips flying. In an instant the rock formation was broken. Huang Rong and the other four were badly alarmed, and dodged this way and that to avoid the stones falling from the air.
Now State Preceptor Jinlun could have left the formation as easily as turning his hand. Instead he went over from defence to attack, his left palm reaching out to seize Huang Rong. Yang Guo jabbed the tip of his staff at his back. The State Preceptor swung his iron wheel slantwise to fend it off, but his left palm was already on Huang Rong’s shoulder. She could have dodged by leaping back, but she heard a fierce rush of wind: a great rock in the air was crashing down right behind her. She had no choice but to use the Great Grappling Hand3 and hook the State Preceptor’s left wrist. “Good!” cried the State Preceptor. He let her hook his wrist, and just as she was using his momentum to fling him outwards, he suddenly called up his tremendous strength and wrenched her in towards him.
On an ordinary day Huang Rong could have turned the force aside and broken free, but now her neili was not enough. With a cry of “Aiyo,” she fell. Yang Guo was horrified. Heedless of life and death, he flung himself forward and threw his arms round the State Preceptor’s legs, and the two of them crashed to the ground together.
State Preceptor Jinlun’s martial arts were far beyond Yang Guo’s, after all. Before he even hit the ground, his right palm lashed out at Yang Guo’s right chest. Yang Guo threw up his left arm to block. With a smack, palm met arm, and Yang Guo felt the blood surge and churn in his chest. His body went flying like a bundle of straw. At that very moment the last great boulder in the air came crashing down and, as luck would have it, slammed squarely into the State Preceptor’s back. The blow was crushing. However strong his neigong, he could not withstand it. He summoned his strength and sent the boulder bouncing off, but his body swayed a few times and at last he pitched forward on his face.
In a moment the stones had fallen and the formation was broken, and Huang Rong, Yang Guo, and the State Preceptor all lay wounded on the ground.
Author’s Note
The central conceptual conflict of this novel concerns the Song-dynasty belief that Yang Guo (as disciple) could not marry Xiaolongnü (as teacher). A certain professor of physics has formally raised the question: on what basis in Song-dynasty ritual and law was a teacher forbidden to marry? He argues that Song attitudes toward the barrier of ritual propriety4 were in fact quite relaxed, citing Li Qingzhao’s5 remarriage after widowhood as evidence. In truth, Song attitudes toward ritual propriety were anything but relaxed. That a certain individual violated the ritual code does not prove that the code did not exist. That cases of sons murdering fathers and mothers occur from time to time in present-day China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan does not prove that contemporary Chinese society condones patricide and matricide. The commonly recognised concepts of a society are usually not recorded in written law. For instance, the prohibition against marriage between father and daughter, or between mother and son, has been universally acknowledged since antiquity, yet the Analects, Mozi, Buddhist sutras, and Daoist canons generally do not mention it. That Confucius and Mencius did not explicitly condemn such marriages does not mean they approved of them. That a certain event or person existed in a certain era does not mean that era approved of or condoned that event or person. The example of Li Qingzhao does not withstand simple logic. That the Song dynasty had the traitor Qin Hui, and the Ming dynasty had Wu Sangui,6 does not prove that the people of the Song and Ming approved of their treachery. That the contemporary era produced Lin Biao and the Gang of Four does not prove that contemporary people condone them. Natural scientists do not study logic, but their reasoning must conform to logic. In science, a single isolated case is insufficient to prove the existence or non-existence of something.
The institution of marriage is among the most complex in human society. The people of the Song placed great emphasis on the Three Bonds and Five Constants, equating “teacher” with “father”, hence the compound term shifu (teacher-father). In the eyes of Song people, marrying one’s teacher was nearly equivalent to marrying one’s mother, or “marrying one’s elder brother’s widow.” Ouyang Xiu,7 a great Confucian scholar of the Song dynasty whose moral character and literary achievements were revered by all, once wrote a “romantic lyric” about his young niece: “Even then, when we met, I had already taken notice, how much more so now.” For this, he was falsely accused of committing adultery with his niece (though in truth nothing of the sort occurred), sparking a tremendous scandal that nearly cost him his life. In reality, attitudes toward marriage constantly shift with the times. During the Western Han, Liu Ying,8 Emperor Hui, son of the dynasty’s founder Liu Bang (Emperor Gaozu), married his own niece Lady Zhang as his empress upon ascending the throne. Lady Zhang was the daughter of Princess Luyuan, who was the daughter of Liu Bang and elder sister of Emperor Hui, and had married Zhang Ao. Emperor Hui made Lady Zhang his empress partly because he had been fond of this niece since childhood, and partly at the instigation of his mother, Empress Lü. Princess Luyuan was Empress Lü’s daughter, and Lady Zhang was Empress Lü’s granddaughter. Empress Lü favoured “adding kinship to kinship.” In the Han dynasty, a niece could become empress and serve as mother to the realm. By the Song dynasty, writing a romantic poem about one’s niece nearly cost a man his life. One can see how drastically attitudes had shifted. Among certain of China’s ethnic minorities, marriage customs differ again. Wang Zhaojun,9 sent in political marriage to the Xiongnu, became the wife of the Chanyu10 Huhanye and bore him a son, who became the Rizhu King of the Right. After Huhanye’s death, his eldest son by another wife, Fuzhulei Ruodi Chanyu, succeeded him and, following Xiongnu custom, took Wang Zhaojun as his own wife, that is, married his stepmother, and she later bore him two daughters.
The new marriage law revised in China in the early 1980s stipulates in Article 6 that “marriage is prohibited between collateral relatives within three generations”, that is, between cousins. The prohibition against marriage between paternal cousins has a long history in China (in remote rural villages and mountainous areas, paternal cousins who fell in love and had secret relations were sometimes killed).
Article 2 of the new marriage law stipulates “the implementation of family planning”. In the future, relationships such as maternal cousins, nieces, uncles, and paternal cousins will be greatly reduced, and relations between men and women will become much simpler.
In earlier times in China, marriage between those sharing the same surname was forbidden. In later generations, this prohibition gradually relaxed, but marriage between paternal cousins remained forbidden. Foreign countries do not necessarily have such rules. In the great English novelist Emily Brontë’s masterpiece Wuthering Heights, the avenger forces his niece to marry his own son (cousins marrying). In old China, this would have been perfectly natural, but the new marriage law does not permit it.
That teachers and students cannot fall in love and marry, this concept persisted in modern China as well. When Shen Congwen11 was teaching at Peking University, he pursued his student Ms. Zhang Zhaohe (later Madam Shen). Ms. Zhang was displeased and complained to her teacher Hu Shi,12 who encouraged her to accept, and the two were eventually married. In the 1970s and 1980s, Taiwan Normal University experienced several teacher-student romance scandals. At the time, Taiwanese public opinion was in an uproar, holding that teachers and students should not fall in love. The author of the martial arts classic Legend of the Swordsmen of the Mountains of Shu, Mister Li Shouwen13 (Huanzhu Louzhu), in his youth worked as a private tutor for a Mister Sun in Tianjin, teaching Mister Sun Zhongsan’s daughter and son. The second daughter, Sun Jingxun, and Mister Li grew close over time and fell deeply in love. Sun Zhongsan opposed teacher-student romance and forbade them from seeing each other. Miss Sun ran away from home and filed a complaint with the Tianjin Women’s Association. Sun Zhongsan colluded with the British concession authorities in Tianjin to have Mister Li arrested and brought to court. At the trial, Miss Sun testified that she was an adult (twenty-four years old) and had voluntarily chosen to marry Li Shouwen. The judge could not convict on the charge of “teacher-student romance” and had no choice but to release him. Later Mister Li and Miss Sun married. It was one of the famous “teacher-student romance” disputes of the northern China of that era.
Footnotes
-
巽位 (Xùn Wèi). xun trigram position, representing wind and the southeast direction in the Eight Trigrams system. Huang Rong’s commands use trigram terminology to direct the rearrangement of the formation. ↩
-
斤 — jīn. Traditional Chinese unit of weight, approximately 500 grams or 1.1 pounds. See Wuxia Wiki. ↩
-
大擒拿手 (Dà Qínná Shǒu). “Great Grappling Hand.” An advanced joint-locking and grappling technique that targets the opponent’s joints and acupoints to immobilise or throw them. ↩
-
礼教大防 (Lǐjiào Dàfáng). “The Great Barrier of Ritual Propriety.” The “ritual teachings” (礼教) refers to the Confucian ethical code governing social relationships and hierarchies. “great barrier” (大防) is the inviolable boundary these codes establish — in this chapter, specifically the prohibition against marriage between teacher and student, which Song dynasty society regarded as akin to incest. Jin Yong’s extended authorial note at the end of this chapter discusses the historical and cross-cultural dimensions of this taboo at length. ↩
-
李清照 (Lǐ Qīngzhào). Li Qingzhao (1084–c.1155), one of China’s greatest poets. After her first husband Zhao Mingcheng died, she later remarried — a fact sometimes cited to argue that Song society was relaxed about widow remarriage. Jin Yong argues this single case does not reflect prevailing social norms. ↩
-
吴三桂 (Wú Sānguì). Wu Sangui (1612–1678), a Ming general who opened Shanhai Pass to the Manchu invaders, enabling the Qing conquest of China. He is remembered as one of history’s great traitors. ↩
-
欧阳修 — Ōuyáng Xiū. (1007–1072) One of the greatest literary figures of the Northern Song dynasty. Statesman, historian, essayist, and poet, he was a leading figure in the Classical Prose Movement. His ci poetry was celebrated for its emotional depth and lyrical beauty. See Wikipedia. ↩
-
刘盈 (Liú Yíng). Emperor Hui of Han (210–188 BCE), the second emperor of the Western Han dynasty. His marriage to his niece Zhang Yan was arranged by his mother Empress Lü. ↩
-
王昭君 (Wáng Zhāojūn). One of the “Four Great Beauties” of ancient China. During the Western Han, she was sent as a bride to the Xiongnu Chanyu as part of a peace alliance (heqin). After her first husband’s death, Xiongnu custom required her to marry his son. ↩
-
单于 (Chányú). Title of the supreme ruler of the Xiongnu, equivalent to “Khan” or “Emperor.” ↩
-
沈从文 (Shěn Cóngwén). Shen Congwen (1902–1988), one of modern China’s greatest writers, known for his lyrical depictions of rural life in western Hunan. His pursuit of his student Zhang Zhaohe, and their eventual marriage, was a celebrated literary romance. ↩
-
胡适 (Hú Shì). Hu Shi (1891–1962), a leading Chinese intellectual, philosopher, and diplomat. Key figure in the New Culture Movement, he advocated for vernacular literature and pragmatic reform. ↩
-
李寿民 (Lǐ Shòumín). Li Shoumin (1902–1961), pen name Huanzhu Louzhu (还珠楼主), author of the monumental martial arts fantasy series Legend of the Swordsmen of the Mountains of Shu (蜀山剑侠传), which deeply influenced the wuxia genre. ↩
